• Skip to main content
  • Skip to header right navigation
  • Skip to site footer
cropped-rhj-header-logo-transparent-background-e1619110790271.png

Radio Health Journal

The latest in health, science, technology, and the intersection of medicine and public policy.

  • Home
  • Archive
    • Full Segment Archive
    • Advanced Search
    • Filters
    • Recent Segments
    • Segment Type
      • Feature Stories
      • Inside Looks
      • Medical Notes
    • Taxonomies
      • Books & Publications
      • Guests
      • Institutions & Organizations
      • Medical Conditions
      • Medical Journals
      • Program Numbers
      • Topics Archive
  • How to Listen
    • Podcast & Other Digital Outlets
    • Terrestrial Broadcast
    • Ways to Listen Overview
  • About
    • About Radio Health Journal
    • Contact Us
    • FAQ
    • Our Team
  • Affiliates
    • Affiliate Login
    • Become an Affiliate
    • Benefits of Being an Affiliate
    • More About Syndicated Radio Programming
    • Public Affairs & FCC Requirements FAQ
    • Sample Programs
Moral Injury

Moral Injury

You are here: Home / Archive / Feature Stories / Moral Injury
Published: January 18, 2015 by RHJ Producer

The military is beginning to recognize a new category of emotional and spiritual injury in war–moral injury, a result of committing or witnessing an event such as an atrocity that violate deeply held ethical beliefs. Experts discuss evolution of the concept, how moral injury occurs, and what psychologists are doing to prevent and treat it when it occurs.


Guest Information:

  • Dr. Brett Litz, clinical psychologist, VA Boston Healthcare System and Director, Mental Health Core, Massachusetts Veterans Epidemiological Research & Information Center
  • Dr. William Nash, co-editor, Combat Stress Injury: Theory, Research & Management and independent consultant, Boston VA Research Institute

Transcript
Email Download New Tab

15-03 Moral Injury

Reed Pence: When we think of soldiers returning from active duty in a combat zone, one of our biggest concerns is about PTSD, or post-traumatic stress disorder. It’s a familiar term today. Back in World War I, people used to call it shell shock. In World War II it was battle fatigue. PTSD was first used to describe trauma suffered in Vietnam. And now there’s yet another term, something new, something called moral injury, which for the first time takes into consideration the emotional and spiritual injuries of war.

Brett Litz: Moral injury is defined as an experience that reflects a transgression of deeply held beliefs. PTSD as a mental disorder is most often however seen as a mental illness that derives from serious life threat experiences — danger-based experiences. And moral injury is more than that.

Reed Pence: If a soldier commits an atrocity or witnesses a leader commit one, for example, that may trigger moral injury, according to Dr. Brett Litz, a clinical psychologist at the VA Boston Healthcare System and Director of the Mental Health Core of the Massachusetts Veterans Epidemiological Research and Information Center.

Brett Litz: What we believe is that moral injury as an outcome has some PTSD-like manifestations in this form of re-experiencing or being haunted, and then being avoidant because it’s painful to think about. And also shutdown interpersonally because of shame about what took place, but also there are other sequelae that aren’t captured well by the PTSD syndrome. These are self-handicappings, especially if your moral injury reflects a perpetration of some sort. Then individuals may not feel deserving of happiness and deserving of a good life.

Reed Pence: Litz says vets suffering from moral injury might ignore their health, drive recklessly, drink too much, or become suicidal.

Brett Litz: But also moral injury affects people at a spiritual level, and it may not be faith-based but it could be that they’re sort of lost and their moral compass is broken, if you will. And they’re demoralized.

Reed Pence: Many service members block both the memories and emotions associated with moral transgressions.

William Nash: There’s an awful lot of veterans of World War II, Korea, and every other conflict who compartmentalized successfully. You know, they keep all that nastiness in one closed-up box for a good part of their life, and maybe it leaks out in alcohol abuse or a little bit of temper outbursts or maybe not at all.

Reed Pence: That’s Dr. William Nash, former Navy psychiatrist, co-editor of the book Combat Stress Injury: Theory, Research, and Management, and an independent consultant with the Boston VA Research Institute.

William Nash: But then maybe somewhere later on in their life when their coping skills expire, run out, as coping skills all do, they’re all perishable. So sooner or later their ability to keep those wartime experiences compartmentalized to the extent they haven’t really worked through them, and made sense out of them, and made peace with them. Sooner or later there is a good chance they’ll become problematic.

Reed Pence: Nash tells the story of a Marine Gunnery Sergeant he treated after the Vietnam War. The sergeant seemed fine when he returned home and showed no signs of PTSD: no depression, no anxiety, nothing.

William Nash: Until one night he was watching TV at home, and his two daughters who were like eight and ten, were lying on the floor together on the carpet. They fall asleep while watching TV, and they’re just lying there side-by-side. It’s a very nice domestic scene, and he looks down at them and he freaks out, and he snaps and he is never the same again. And he ended up being admitted to the inpatient unit, because he was going out at night with camouflage paint on his face, and he was going out at night crawling through the bushes with a loaded weapon.

Reed Pence: Nash eventually found the root cause of the Sergeant’s change.

William Nash: He recalled an event in Vietnam in which he and some other Marines leveled a Vietnamese village supposedly inhabited by Viet Cong. And he remembers shooting an anti-tank rocket into this straw hooch and blowing it up and it burns. And then after the fire goes out he goes to examine what was in the hooch and he sees two girls lying side-by-side, about ages eight and ten, burnt to a crisp in this hooch. But he totally forgets this memory until that night when he’s watching TV with his two daughters, and from then on he just could not live with himself.

Reed Pence: Not everyone in the military believes moral injury is real. But the same was said about PTSD when it first appeared as a mental health term in the 1980s.

William Nash: Without research to really help us learn more about what were the specific symptoms to look for, and more importantly what was the underlying mechanism of injury, or if it even was an injury. It was just a lot of opportunity for misconceptions. And I remember vividly in the 1980s when I did my psychiatry training and first started treating Vietnam veterans with PTSD, we believed that they had these problems years after the war because they had problems before the war. We believed that a lot of them had pre-existing personality disorders or other life problems or predispositions or something that made them somehow not adapt as well as the other people.

Reed Pence: Research eventually changed that perception of PTSD. Today, moral injury faces the same kind of challenge.

William Nash: And it’s only now, in this war, that we’re beginning to get evidence and see that definitely it isn’t just the weak ones that crumble under stress that end up with a long-term disability. It can and does happen to anyone, and it really is a confirmation of this idea that these are truly injuries.

Reed Pence: One way military leaders hope to prevent moral injury is to prepare soldiers for the horrific situations they may encounter in battling counter-insurgency.

William Nash: Obviously, you can’t prepare someone for the unthinkable, but at least if they are given a chance to experience it through very realistic combat scenarios and training in which children, pregnant women, or old ladies are collaterally killed, unintentionally killed, or intentionally killed, because they are perhaps themselves suicide bombers or some of the other many horrible things that could happen. If, at least, they’re given a chance to role-play these experiences beforehand they might, and then, with good leadership debriefing each training exercise to say okay now if this happens to us for real how are we going to deal with this? So there are people working on that, it’s just very early in the game.

Reed Pence: Prevention of moral injury is obviously the best-case scenario. But how do you treat moral injury once it has taken hold?

Brett Litz: We’ve developed a therapy to target moral injury that we’re testing with Marines, and we did an initial pilot study with Marines and now we’re doing a clinical trial comparing this therapy called adaptive disclosure with an evidence-based therapy that’s used in the VA and the DoD called cognitive processing therapy. There are numerous potentially traumatic experiences and losses and potentially morally injurious experiences that may haunt the person, or they may be having a hard time adapting to. What we seek in this therapy is to get at what is principally harming, what is most haunting, most distressing currently.

Reed Pence: Litz says the technique is akin to a confession. The patient tells the narrative of what they did or saw that was a transgression of deeply held moral values.

Brett Litz: The idea is to get at the raw details and unearth the painful aspects of the experience, and to lay out its meaning and implication in terms of this person, and how they feel about themselves and the world, and their role in the military.

Reed Pence: Then the patient imagines sharing these transgressions with a mentor, such as his father, a chaplain, or a revered coach, someone who the patient has regarded as a compassionate moral authority.

Brett Litz: Share this experience with that person, and hear and voice what this compassionate moral authority would say about that event. And what we’re trying to promote is this idea that moral repair is possible. So if you have someone in your life that loves you and is compassionate about you, but yet is a moral authority, and hears about a transgression — they’ll be upset about that, and they’ll want you to make it right, and they’ll encourage you to make it right because they know you can and that you have goodness in you. So rather than this coming from the therapist, who will have no credibility about that kind of matter, we have the service member in imagination have this dialogue with this compassionate moral authority in their lives, and for them to share what this person is saying about this event and this transgression.

Reed Pence: Nash suggests another approach to healing moral injury as well.

William Nash: The knee-jerk reaction is to say, “oh my gosh it’s all my fault, I’m terrible.” But it’s only when you can really tolerate all that shame and guilt that you can say, “wait a minute now, this is my responsibility, this part is my culpability but this part isn’t.” But it begins with being able to tolerate the horrible emotions, and that’s one of the reasons mindfulness meditation is becoming more and more popular among warfighters. Marines are using it for a number of things, just because it’s a type of meditation where one just tolerates. You sit with yourself, allow the emotions to break on the beach like waves, and just let it be, and then as you develop a tolerance for the emotions then you can start to make sense out of them.

Reed Pence: The concept of moral injury isn’t new. Philosophers and theologians have discussed moral repair and the violations of a shared moral covenant since the antiquity. It’s just that the concept is new to the military.

William Nash: There’s, fortunately, a good number of leaders in the military, at DoD, in the service branches, who understand this and realize that one of the best things they can do for their service members and their families who have felt betrayed by their experiences in wartime is for the services, service branches, and DoD to try to restore their faith in the military as an essentially good institution.

Reed Pence: What is it that makes an experience impossible to incorporate into one’s identity? Researchers believe moral emotions such as shame, guilt, and rage are at the heart of the matter, but they have a long way to go to understand moral injury, as well as diagnose and treat it. In the meantime, families and friends of servicemembers can only do their best to offer support and understanding. If you are a present or former service member and think you might be suffering from moral injury, or if you think you know someone who is, you can call the veterans crisis line at 1-800-273-T-A-L-K or find a link on our website radiohealthjournal.net.

Our writer/producer this week is Polly Hansen. I’m Reed Pence.

Scroll back to top

Sign up to receive email updates

Enter your name and email address below and I’ll send you periodic updates about the podcast.

powered by

Program #: 15-03Segment Type: Feature StoriesTopics: Behavioral Science| Mental Health| Military, War and Veterans| Psychology and Psychiatry| Stress and Stress Management| Trauma| Violence and AbuseMedical Conditions: Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)Guests: Dr. Brett Litz| Dr. William NashPublications: Combat Stress Injury: Theory Research & ManagementInstitutions & Organizations: Boston VA Research Institute| Massachusetts Veterans Epidemiological Research and Information Center
  • 110Share on Facebook
  • 101Share on Twitter
  • 70Share on Instagram
  • 60Share on LinkedIn
  • 83Share on Pinterest
  • 45Share on Reddit
  • 142Share on Email

Related Segments:

Genetic Testing For Drug Effectiveness

Long Term Psychological Damage of Natural Disasters

Long Term Psychological Damage of Natural Disasters

Research Ethics Now Vs. Then: A Case Study

Research Ethics Now vs. Then: A Case Study (2021)

How To Overcome Your Mental Blocks To Reach Success

Hangovers

Healthcare and the Homeless

Healthcare and the Homeless

Previous Post:Making and Breaking Habits
Next Post:Music ThanatologyMusic Thanatology

About RHJ Producer

Since 1992, Radio Health Journal has been bringing listeners useful, verifiable information they can trust and rely on in the fields of medicine, science & technology, research, and the intersection of health & public policy. Both Radio Health Journal and sister show Viewpoints Radio are AURN productions.

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sidebar


AURN Podcasts


Trending Topics

Public Health and Public Safety

Research and Clinical Trials

Health Care

News and Headlines

Mental Health

Behavioral Science

Family and Interpersonal Relationships

Covid-19 Pandemic

Nutrition and Diet

Technology


Latest Headlines

Medical Notes: Poor Sleep Can Change Your Brain, How to Grill Safely This Summer, and the Secret Superpower of Optimism

Medical Notes: How to Change Your Personality, Customizing Your Anxiety Treatment, and a Hidden Cause of Infertility

Medical Notes: How Sleep Apnea Rewires Your Brain, A Non-Addictive Pain Pill, And Using Ultrasound As A Disinfectant

Medical Notes: The Science Behind Your ‘AURA’, The Fluoride Debate, And The Real Reason Behind Your Yawn

Medical Notes: How Fish Oil Slows Aging, The Loneliness Epidemic, And How To Better Understand Autism


Most Discussed

Empty Nose Syndrome: When a Routine Nose Surgery Goes Wrong

Lewy Body Dementia

Can IUDs and Other Contraceptives Trigger Autoimmune Disease?

Can IUDs & Other Contraceptives Trigger Autoimmune Disease?


Covid-19 Pandemic

Children Are The Future, So Why Is Childcare Breaking Down?

Public Health And Politics: A Look At The Mistakes Made During The Pandemic

Does A Good Bedside Manner Save Lives?


Check out our sister show Viewpoints Radio

  • Culture Crash: Yes, “The Bear” Is Still That Good
  • Viewpoints Explained: New Questions Emerge Around Spacex And Nasa’s Mission To Mars
  • Why More Retirees Are Choosing This Option
  • Why Are All Major U.S. Cities Sinking?
  • Culture Crash: James Gunn’s Superman: The Hero The DC Universe Desperately Needs
  • Viewpoints Explained: Afghanistan, Four Years On: What’s Left For Women Under Taliban Rule?
  • Burning Year-Round: The New Reality Of Firefighting In America
  • Highways To Displacement: The Hidden History Of Urban Renewal
  • Culture Crash: Where’s The Song Of The Summer?

Archives

↑

Stay up-to-date on the latest trends in public health, science, tech, research & more.

Enter your email address to get notifications & instant access to new Radio Health Journal segments as they are released.

Name
Email
Become an affiliate

Start airing Radio Health Journal on your platform to satisfy FCC OPIF requirements, including quarterly issues/programming reports.

Become an Affiliate

Connect

Interact with us by sharing comments, favorite segments, questions or even suggest a topic.

  • Facebook link
  • Twitter link
  • Instagram link
  • Pinterest link
  • Spotify link
  • YouTube channel link
  • rss feed link
  • contactemail

American Urban Radio Networks (AURN) logo

Listen

Archive

Broadcast

Guests

Podcast & Digital Outlets

Recently Aired

Taxonomies

Topics

Ways to Listen

Learn

About Us

Affiliates

Contact Info

FAQ

Our Team

Public Affairs & FCC Requirements

AURN.com

Sitemap

© Copyright 2024 – American Urban Radio Networks | All Rights Reserved

↑ Return to top

Radio Health Journal Newsletter SignupStay up-to-date on the latest trends in public health, science, tech, research & more.

Subscribe to get the latest from Radio Health Journal directly in your inbox.

Name
[email protected]